The debate around AI seems to continue to become more heated and more relevant with each passing year. In the U.S., a gap between the opinions of large tech corporations and seems to continually grow; the showed this in the national support for restrictions placed on data centers. For example, Michigan voters elected Jocelyn Benson, the former Secretary of State whose campaign promised to place a on the building of data centers in Michigan, as governor. Among the many criticisms that AI and its usage have faced, the environmental impacts of the data centers that are used to make the technology possible have played a key part in the conflict.
According to the Environmental and Energy Study Institute (EESI), large data centers can consume up to of water per day, the same amount as a city of 50,000 people. Critics of data centers often point to the water usage of data centers as one of the primary reasons they must be opposed, claiming that they deprive humans and other living beings of a necessary resource for survival in order to funnel it into a technology that is distinctly not. argue that the water consumption of data centers is small compared to other water uses such as agriculture, or even
In my opinion, this rebuttal is fundamentally flawed. While it may be true that data centers are by far not the largest consumers of water in the U.S., that doesn’t invalidate the criticisms that have been brought forth against data centers. The difference here is that data centers and AI do not provide the same benefit to humans as clean water, food, hygiene and many of the other things water is used for. AI is, at its best, a tool for human use, and at its worst, actively harmful to the livelihoods of humans. We do not need water for AI in the same way that we must drink it, or that plants need it to grow.
Alongside this, AI is becoming more and more difficult to avoid, especially due to its widespread and insistent usage by large tech corporations. The technology is being integrated into so many aspects of our daily technology use, with now being packaged with a seemingly inseparable “AI overview” for even the most mundane of searches, or new phones being marketed with their . If you are using Google Chrome to read this article, you may have a shortcut for Google’s AI, Gemini, at the top of your screen. Large companies use their platforms in order to , making the option to turn it off, and the knowledge that it was happening in the first place, obscure. And every single time that AI is used without the knowledge or consent of the user, pushed onto us by corporations, the environmental impact worsens, adding up with the amount of people who unwittingly generate a screen of text with every simple Google search.
One must eat, one must drink. One must choose to shower and use the restroom, or to water their lawn. Unfortunately, it is becoming increasingly difficult to choose not to interact with AI in some way. I believe there is a lot more to the arguments around the ethics of data centers that cannot be countered by simply talking about the statistics of water consumption, or even any other more damning statistics involving the environmental impact of data centers. At the end of the day, I don’t think that pointing to these numbers changes most of what is fundamentally wrong about data centers, the modern state of AI implementation, and the purpose for which the environmental impact, no matter how large or small you argue it to be, is being created. Clean water is a precious resource and a necessity that far too many humans already suffer from a lack of. We have to remember that water is for living beings first and foremost.
The Student Movement is the official student newspaper of 星空无限传媒. Opinions expressed in the Student Movement are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the editors, 星空无限传媒 or the Seventh-day Adventist church.
